menu
small logo

Back

Horayot

Daf 14b

אִיבַּעֲיָא לְהוּ: רַבִּי זֵירָא וְרַבָּה בַּר רַב מַתָּנָה הֵי מִנַּיְיהוּ עָדִיף? רַבִּי זֵירָא חָרִיף וּמַקְשֶׁה, וְרַבָּה בַּר רַב מַתָּנָה מָתוּן וּמַסִּיק, מַאי? תֵּיקוּ. הדרן עלך כהן משיח וסליקא לה מסכת הוריות

A dilemma was raised before the Sages: Between Rabbi Zeira and Rabba bar Rav Mattana, which of them is preferable? Rabbi Zeira is incisive and raises pertinent difficulties, and Rabba bar Rav Mattana is moderate and not so incisive, but ultimately he draws the appropriate conclusions. What is the conclusion? Which is preferable? The Gemara concludes: The dilemma shall stand unresolved.

RASHI

חריף ומקשה מתוך פלפול יתירא דהוה ליה הוה מקשה ומתרץ אבל רבה בר מתנה לא הוה חריף כל כך אלא מתוך שהוא שוהה ומעיין יפה יפה מסיק אליבא דהלכתא:

SUMMARY

In defining the nasi and the anointed priest, it was stated that with regard to the sin-offering brought for absence of awareness, the verses must be followed precisely. Only a High Priest anointed with the anointing oil is liable to bring a bull as a sin-offering. The nasi mentioned in the Torah is the king, one who heads a large congregation of Jews and with regard to whom no other Jew is in a superior position. Consequently, there could conceivably be several Jewish kings who simultaneously fall into the category of nasi, provided that they are not subject to one another’s authority. There is a difference between the High Priest and the king: The High Priest maintains his lofty status and brings his unique sin-offering even if he sinned after he was no longer serving as High Priest, while the king brings his unique sin-offering only if he sinned while he was king. The Gemara’s statement that a High Priest who was not anointed is on a lower level than an anointed High Priest applies only to the sin-offering brought for his own erroneous ruling and a transgression performed on the basis of that ruling. With regard to all other mitzvot stated in the Torah concerning a High Priest, there is no difference between them. A former High Priest maintains his status with regard to all aspects of the High Priesthood, except for the fact that he does not bring the tenth of an ephah meal-offering brought by the High Priest daily and does not sacrifice the bull of Yom Kippur. The status of a priest anointed for war is like that of a High Priest with regard to all the prohibitions that apply to a High Priest, but his level of sanctity is lower, and when he dies he does not restore the unwitting murderer to his home from the city of refuge. Apropos the definition of an anointed priest, the Gemara discussed the halakhot of the anointing of the priest and the king. The anointing oil prepared by Moses is especially sacred, and is used only to anoint the High Priest and kings from the house of David. A king who is the son of a king is anointed only when there is some controversy with regard to his ascendency to the throne. The Gemara briefly discussed the differences between a High Priest and an ordinary priest. It is prohibited for a High Priest to marry a widow, in addition to the prohibition against his marrying a divorcée, which applies to an ordinary priest as well, and a High Priest is commanded to marry only a virgin. A High Priest may not become ritually impure even to bury a close relative, while an ordinary priest may become ritually impure in that case. A High Priest does not rend his garments in the manner that one typically rends his garments as an expression of mourning. A High Priest performs the Temple service as an acute mourner, on the day that one of his relatives dies, even though he may not partake of the offerings sacrificed that day. The lofty status of the High Priest relative to the rest of the Jewish people applies with regard to his sanctity. In terms of deference, the deference due the king is greater than the deference due the High Priest. In terms of precedence, the principle is: With regard to rescuing individuals and the return of a lost item, one whose position in the Temple is more significant precedes one whose position in the Temple is less significant. Likewise, one whose lineage is noble precedes others, and one whose lineage is flawed is preceded by others. There are certain cases where a man precedes a woman, and others where a woman precedes a man. On a similar note, there are different levels among the Sages, both in terms of choosing the one who is appointed to a position and in terms of the deference due to each Sage. All these matters of precedence apply when the people in question are equals in Torah knowledge. A Torah scholar, even if his lineage is flawed, precedes all others, even a king and a High Priest. There are several aggadic passages in this chapter. Some relate to the anointing oil, specifically, how it was prepared, who was anointed with it throughout the generations, and how it was sequestered. In addition, the Gemara related different incidents that transpired with regard to various personalities in the Bible, and events that occurred during the tannaitic and amoraic eras.