menu
small logo

Back

How Is the Composition of a Court Determined?

The Resolution

The Talmud resolves the apparent contradiction between the ruling of the mishna and the statement of Rabbi Elazar by explaining the situation to which the mishna refers.

The Gemara answers: It is as Rabbi Yohanan said elsewhere: The Sages taught with regard to the laymen’s courts in Syria. Here, too, the mishna is addressing a similar situation: They taught the halakha in the mishna with regard to the laymen’s courts in Syria, where even a debtor can refuse to be judged before the court chosen by the creditor, and claim that they are not worthy judges. But, by inference, if the creditor chooses a court of experts, the debtor does not have the right to refuse to be judged before them.