Back
Kashrut
The Prohibition of Cooking Meat in MilkA piece of meat can be strictly kosher, and milk and its products might also be fully kosher, but if they are cooked together, not only will the meal not be kosher, but the utensils and dishes in which they were cooked will become non-kosher, and they must undergo a process to render them kosher once again. The separation between meat and milk is a central feature of a kosher kitchen.
Further reading: For more on the prohibition of cooking meat and milk together, see A Concise Guide to the Torah, pp. 193, 225, 469.
According to Torah law, it is prohibited to cook meat and milk together. It is also prohibited to eat meat and milk that were cooked together, or even to derive any benefit from meat and milk that were cooked together. Consequently, it is even prohibited to feed this mixture to one’s animals or to sell it to a gentile.
In the case of poultry with milk, only the middle of the three aforementioned prohibitions applies. That is, it is prohibited to eat poultry with milk. There is no prohibition against cooking them together, nor is it prohibited to derive benefit from the mixture. Consequently, it is permitted to feed such food to house pets or to sell it to a gentile. Nevertheless, the vessel in which it was cooked is considered not kosher.
Over the generations, in order to prevent confusion and error, the Sages have maintained that one should have separate sets of dishes for meat and dairy foods. Likewise, the Sages instituted that those participating in the same meal, or even if they are merely eating separate meals at a single table, should not eat meat and milk at the same time, unless they are eating on separate tablecloths or placemats.
The category of meat includes the meat itself, its soup, the sauce made from it, and any food that contains meat. In practice, one should be careful even regarding foods that have been cooked in a pot used for meat. For all these, one should use not only specific cooking pots and baking utensils, but also separate sets of dishes and cutlery.
In order to prevent mistakes, it is customary to have distinguishing marks to separate dishes and utensils used for milk or meat. It is also best to use different tablecloths for meat and dairy meals.
Furthermore, one should not wash meat and dairy vessels together after use. In many homes, two separate sinks are installed in the kitchen for this purpose, to avoid mistakes. In any case in which a dairy utensil was used for meat dishes or vice versa, it is possible that the utensil has been rendered non-kosher and is now prohibited for use. If one wishes to keep the item and continue using it, he must ask a rabbi how to kasher it.
Further reading: For details, see the chapter on kashering kitchenware, p. 560. The source for the halakha of kashering kitchenware can be found in A Concise Guide to the Torah, p. 419; A Concise Guide to the Sages, p. 216.
This separation between meat and dairy applies to almost all kitchenware items. Special care should be taken with regard to earthenware, metal, and wooden products, as well as ceramics. It is permitted to use the same drinking glasses for meat and dairy meals (after they have been thoroughly washed, of course), but many maintain separate glasses nonetheless.
The use of items made of plastic materials raises many halakhic problems. To avoid situations of uncertainty, one must be very careful to use completely different utensils of this type for meat and dairy.
In addition to the prohibition against eating meat and milk together, the Sages decreed that one must wait a certain period of time between eating meat and consuming milk and dairy products.
After eating a meat meal, it is customary in many Jewish communities to wait six hours before drinking milk or eating dairy products. According to various local customs, this waiting period is shorter.
By contrast, the waiting time after consuming dairy foods before eating meat is only half an hour, or an hour at most. It is recommended, however, to be strict to wait after eating hard cheese, meaning cheese that is aged for at least six months, as one does after eating meat. Some kashrut agencies post lists of cheeses in this category, which can be found online.
Foods that contain neither meat nor dairy products are called pareve (also spelled parve), meaning “neutral.” These may be eaten with either meat or milk. It is worthwhile to clarify whether any given compound food is pareve by consulting with the individual who made it or by examining the kosher certification of store-bought items.
Managing a kosher kitchen requires the careful monitoring of milk and dairy products.
Of course, one may not cook meat with milk or butter, nor add milk to those side dishes that are served along with meat (e.g., mashed potatoes with butter or milk; quiche that contains cream or cheese). It is also prohibited to serve dairy desserts at the end of a meat meal.
One may cook vegetables or soup with dairy products, but this cooking must be performed in accordance with the dietary laws, as follows:
Cooking with milk and dairy products should be done using only dairy utensils, and the food must be served at a dairy meal. In other words, it is prohibited to cook such food using any pots, pans, knives, baking molds, or ovens that will be used for meat dishes. Similarly, one may not serve this food on plates that are used for meat meals, nor may one use cutlery that is used to eat meat.
In order to cook and bake dairy products, one must have a suitable set of cooking implements that will be used solely for dairy foods. Likewise, the serving dishes, e.g., plates, cups, and cutlery, should not be used for meat dishes.
Nowadays, there are suitable non-dairy substitutes for milk, butter, and cream, and these greatly expand the different culinary options without violating laws of kashrut.
An oven that is used for baking or cooking dairy should not be used to cook meat. It is ideal to have separate ovens for meat and dairy, but if this is not possible, one should consult a rabbi as to how best to use one oven for both meat and dairy.